Which is better, prismatic cells or cylindrical cells?

Prismatic vs. Cylindrical Cells: What is the Difference?

Of course, the most apparent difference between a prismatic cell and a cylindrical cell is the shape.

You can find more information on our web, so please take a look.

Prismatic Cell Characteristics

A prismatic cell is distinctively thin and rectangular, easily formable into battery packs by stacking these cells. The flat shape efficiently retains energy without significant loss, making it ideal for custom applications requiring tailored battery packs.

Cylindrical Cell Features

Cylindrical cells are indeed cylindrical, reminiscent of the AA batteries in remote controls. Despite the challenges in stacking due to their shape, the inherent gaps allow for better airflow and thermal management, crucial for maintaining optimal performance in demanding environments.

Designing battery packs with cylindrical cells can both be advantageous and disadvantageous. The gaps might suggest inefficient space usage but in reality, they promote necessary airflow and prevent swelling. Such qualities make cylindrical cells apt for extreme conditions like space.

Pros and Cons of Lithium Prismatic Cells vs Cylindrical Cells

Given the diverse array of electronics and applications powered by batteries, cells are designed in varying shapes to suit specific needs. Prismatic and cylindrical cells serve distinct purposes depending on factors such as cost, production ease, and capacity range.

Understanding these differences is crucial as the choice influences the design, power capabilities, and potential failure modes of your product.

Battery Cell Shapes and Sizes Explored

Cylindrical cells, resembling those in everyday devices like toys and remotes, are constructed by tightly winding electrodes within a metal can, offering uniform electrolyte and pressure distribution. Their standardized formats, including 14650 and 18650, make them widely used.

Conversely, prismatic cells are flat and rectangular, commonly found in electric and hybrid vehicles. These cells save space but require careful enclosure to mitigate stress on the corners that can lead to cell bloating or deformation.

Prismatic cells are usually custom-made, without universal format adherence, impacting minimum order quantities and necessary certifications.

Voltage and Capacity Comparison

Prismatic cells generally offer larger capacities due to their size and limited connections, making them suitable for high-energy applications. A single prismatic lithium phosphate battery (LifePO4) might provide 3.2 volts and 100Ah capacity.

On the other hand, cylindrical cells, though smaller and requiring more connections, offer higher voltage output and faster discharge rates. Achieving the same amp hours with cylindrical cells would demand several units, albeit with better efficiency in high-performance applications.

While more cylindrical cells might be necessary to match the capacity of a single prismatic cell, their energy efficiency makes them preferable in gadgets demanding long battery life. Prismatic cells excel in dense and energy-intensive setups like storage systems, medical devices, and vehicles.

Construction and Lifecycle Insights

Battery packs are designed based on the alignment of the cells. Cylindrical cells are commonly stacked in series and parallel configurations, allowing for optimal airflow and rapid heat dissipation, thus improving performance.

However, prismatic cells, stacked in series, suffer from heat dissipation issues as touching surfaces impede airflow. Typical prismatic cells last around 2000 cycles, whereas cylindrical cells offer shorter lifespans of 300-500 cycles. Lifecycle management is crucial, especially in handling faulty cells within each type.

Testing, Certifications, and Cost Considerations

Regardless of shape, battery packs must meet testing and certification standards based on cell chemistry and industry requirements. This is especially critical for lithium batteries in both cylindrical and prismatic forms.

Cost-wise, cylindrical cells benefit from ease of manufacturing, having established technologies. Prismatic cells, though potentially more expensive, are priced based on cell size and order volume. Different chemistries like lithium might also impact cost due to more rigorous testing standards compared to nickel-based variants.

Deciding the best cell type involves evaluating power needs, lifecycle, and budget. Prismatic cells offer extensive capacity at higher costs, while cylindrical cells are cost-effective with superior thermal management, albeit at lower capacities, necessitating bulk purchases for parity.

Notably, prismatic cells aren’t off-the-shelf items, complicating small quantity acquisitions and sample testing due to minimum order requirements. Ensuring sample consistency and managing ongoing certifications (such as UL and UN 38.3) for customized prismatic packs are critical considerations in planning

Summary and Recommendations

Manufacturers specify minimum order requirements for both cell types. Some companies specialize in one form or chemistry, whereas others offer varied options. Discussing with your manufacturer helps in selecting the apt cell for your application, ensuring you meet your power needs effectively.

For more cylindrical vs prismatic cells information, please contact us. We will provide professional answers.